Staff
Meet Our Team
Karl Shelly
Pastor: Mission, Peace, and Justice, and Small Groups
Contact Karl via our Contact Form
Karl was born in Columbus, OH. He graduated from Adrian College, BA: Religion & Political Science, 1983, and University of Denver College of Law, JD, 1986.
Karl & his wife Michelle have three adult sons.
Karl previously worked as a lawyer, as a Capitol Hill lobbyist for Mennonite Central Committee, and a mediator in the D.C. court system. He’s been an adjunct professor of Peace, Justice, & Conflict Studies at GC since 2002, and a member of the AMC pastoral team since 1998.
Document written by Karl: Dimensions of Progressive Christianity
Response from Karl to being “charged” with officiating at same-sex wedding.

Anna Yoder Schlabach
Pastor: Worship, Pastoral Care
Contact Anna via our Contact Form

Scott Coulter
Pastor: Congregational Life, Hospitality
Contact Scott via our Contact Form

Moriah Hurst
Pastor: Child, Youth, and Adult Faith Formation
Contact Moriah via our Contact Form
Moriah was born in Harrisonburg, Va but moved around a lot as a child and into adult life. She graduated from Goshen College in 2003 with a degree focusing in bible/religion, English, biology and women’s studies; and AMBS in 2007 with a Mdiv in Youth Ministry.
Moriah is married to Doug.
Moriah worked in Australia with Mennonite Mission Network for 8 years in young adult and youth faith formation ministries. She moved to Harrisonburg, Va in 2016 and was the Nurture and Faith Development Pastor at Park View Mennonite Church for 8 years.
Moriah joined the AMC pastoral team in September 2024.

Lynn Diener
Office Administrator
Lynn is responsible for communication and record-keeping in the church office, coordinates building rentals and volunteers for hospitality tasks, some bookkeeping, and provides administrative support for the church staff.

Dancy Hirschler
Treasurer (Volunteer Position)